{
  "version": "user-six-criteria-20261014",
  "source": "User-confirmed asset acceptance rules, including procedural construction as the sixth criterion.",
  "transcription": "Complete six-item acceptance rules in English, with editorial IDs A3D-01 to A3D-06 and explicit evidence mapping. These are not IDs or numeric weights from a benchmark grader.",
  "scoring": {
    "weights": null,
    "numeric_score": null,
    "rule": "Six separate acceptance statuses; no weighted numeric reward supplied. Partial, missing and unverified remain distinct."
  },
  "criteria": [
    {
      "criterion_id": "A3D-01",
      "requirement": "Accurate written description",
      "weight": null,
      "critical_gate": true,
      "precondition": "Use the identified delivered source-package version; do not substitute newly generated previews for original delivery evidence.",
      "method_and_operation": "Read description and compare structure, units, dimensions and mesh counts.",
      "pass": "Original description agrees with the delivered asset.",
      "partial": "Relevant material exists but only part of the requirement is demonstrated.",
      "missing_or_fail": "Required deliverable absent, or a completed check demonstrates noncompliance.",
      "unverified": "Evidence absent or check not executed; do not treat this as a product failure.",
      "evidence": "Original description, media audit and source audit",
      "execution_status": "completed_in_prior_source_audit",
      "verdict": "pass",
      "current_update": "Source audit reused; no new Blender generator or full export CLI run in this website update."
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "A3D-02",
      "requirement": "Orbit video",
      "weight": null,
      "critical_gate": true,
      "precondition": "Use the identified delivered source-package version; do not substitute newly generated previews for original delivery evidence.",
      "method_and_operation": "Decode the delivered turntable and inspect its full orbit separately from blade motion.",
      "pass": "An actual playable orbit video is delivered; an object action alone is insufficient.",
      "partial": "Relevant material exists but only part of the requirement is demonstrated.",
      "missing_or_fail": "Required deliverable absent, or a completed check demonstrates noncompliance.",
      "unverified": "Evidence absent or check not executed; do not treat this as a product failure.",
      "evidence": "turntable.mp4 and media.json",
      "execution_status": "completed_in_prior_source_audit",
      "verdict": "pass",
      "current_update": "Source audit reused; no new Blender generator or full export CLI run in this website update."
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "A3D-03",
      "requirement": "Multi-angle renders",
      "weight": null,
      "critical_gate": true,
      "precondition": "Use the identified delivered source-package version; do not substitute newly generated previews for original delivery evidence.",
      "method_and_operation": "List and inspect the delivered views and detail renders.",
      "pass": "Multiple actual rendered viewpoints are delivered; textures and thumbnails alone are insufficient.",
      "partial": "Relevant material exists but only part of the requirement is demonstrated.",
      "missing_or_fail": "Required deliverable absent, or a completed check demonstrates noncompliance.",
      "unverified": "Evidence absent or check not executed; do not treat this as a product failure.",
      "evidence": "Eight source render files; six principal views recorded in media.json",
      "execution_status": "completed_in_prior_source_audit",
      "verdict": "pass",
      "current_update": "Source audit reused; no new Blender generator or full export CLI run in this website update."
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "A3D-04",
      "requirement": "Mesh",
      "weight": null,
      "critical_gate": true,
      "precondition": "Use the identified delivered source-package version; do not substitute newly generated previews for original delivery evidence.",
      "method_and_operation": "Read GLB mesh geometry, dimensions and triangle counts.",
      "pass": "Usable mesh geometry exists; mesh embedded in a source project is acceptable.",
      "partial": "Relevant material exists but only part of the requirement is demonstrated.",
      "missing_or_fail": "Required deliverable absent, or a completed check demonstrates noncompliance.",
      "unverified": "Evidence absent or check not executed; do not treat this as a product failure.",
      "evidence": "model.glb and source-audit.json",
      "execution_status": "completed_in_prior_source_audit",
      "verdict": "pass",
      "current_update": "Source audit reused; no new Blender generator or full export CLI run in this website update."
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "A3D-05",
      "requirement": "Editable source project",
      "weight": null,
      "critical_gate": true,
      "precondition": "Use the identified delivered source-package version; do not substitute newly generated previews for original delivery evidence.",
      "method_and_operation": "Open the delivered .blend and inspect editable geometry.",
      "pass": "An editable .blend satisfies this item; an extra Python or Three.js script is not required.",
      "partial": "Relevant material exists but only part of the requirement is demonstrated.",
      "missing_or_fail": "Required deliverable absent, or a completed check demonstrates noncompliance.",
      "unverified": "Evidence absent or check not executed; do not treat this as a product failure.",
      "evidence": "Prior source audit; .blend available in the separate source package",
      "execution_status": "completed_in_prior_source_audit",
      "verdict": "pass",
      "current_update": "Source audit reused; no new Blender generator or full export CLI run in this website update."
    },
    {
      "criterion_id": "A3D-06",
      "requirement": "Parameterized generator",
      "weight": null,
      "critical_gate": true,
      "precondition": "Use the identified delivered source-package version; do not substitute newly generated previews for original delivery evidence.",
      "method_and_operation": "Inspect delivered generator and construction parameters; rebuild with a changed geometry parameter.",
      "pass": "An actual delivered generator changes geometry when a construction parameter changes; camera/material/pose-only controls do not qualify.",
      "partial": "Relevant material exists but only part of the requirement is demonstrated.",
      "missing_or_fail": "Required deliverable absent, or a completed check demonstrates noncompliance.",
      "unverified": "Evidence absent or check not executed; do not treat this as a product failure.",
      "evidence": "generate_asset.py, parameters.json, procedural.json and before/after parameter files",
      "execution_status": "completed_in_prior_source_audit",
      "verdict": "pass",
      "current_update": "Source audit reused; no new Blender generator or full export CLI run in this website update."
    }
  ]
}